If Rene started with the below equation;
The addition and subtraction properties of equality states in order to keep both sides of the equation balanced, you have to subtract or add the same value to both sides.
But Rene added 12 to the left side and subtracted 3 from the right side instead of adding or subtracting the same value to both sides.
So all we need to do balance the equation again is add 15 to the right side of the equation;