401,510 views
8 votes
8 votes
Is it fact or Asimovs opinion that what Whitman admired was a "limited beauty"

User Mohan Ramanathan
by
2.6k points

1 Answer

23 votes
23 votes

This question seems to be incomplete. However, there´s enough information to find the right answer.

Answer: It´s an opinion.

Step-by-step explanation:

In The Roving Mind (1983), Issac Asimov quotes "When I Heard the Learn’d Astronomer," by Walt Whitman to refute the idea that science drains the beauty from gazing at the stars. Asimov claims that Whitman's point of view makes him only be able to detect a "limited beauty", as his disregard of the astronomer's lecture makes him unaware of the beauty behind science. However, his claim his only an opinion, not a fact, because Asimov can only conjecture Whitman´s experience.

User Questzen
by
2.9k points