Register
The Giver Book Let's discuss what you think happened at the novel's conclusion. What was "perhaps only an echo?" Make a case for both sides: Did Jonas and Gabriel live or die? Use textual support to strengthen
461,154 views
27 votes
27 votes
The Giver Book

Let's discuss what you think happened at the novel's conclusion. What was "perhaps
only an echo?" Make a case for both sides: Did Jonas and Gabriel live or die? Use textual support to strengthen your responses. This support can be from any portion of
the novel!

THEY LIVE:


THEY DIE

User Goodbyeera
by
2.9k points

1 Answer

17 votes
17 votes

Answer:

The music Jonas heard was perhaps only an echo.

Step-by-step explanation:

Jonas and Gabriel die because they lost his hope for what they thought to be Elsewhere. They said,"... they were waiting for him;and they were waiting, too, for the baby" (p178-179) which makes me think they died.

User Deadron
by
2.8k points
Ask a Question
Welcome to QAmmunity.org, where you can ask questions and receive answers from other members of our community.

1.6m questions

2.0m answers

Other Questions

This is referring to the Crucible: What is the dispute between John Proctor and Thomas Putnam? What does this dispute foreshadow? Please and thank you!
Her attitude caused her to look ___ her nose at others
PLEASE HELP I AM GIVING ALOTTT OF POINTS Which stage of the Hero's Journey do you see the most in Percy Jackson Ch. 7 The Lightning Thief also give a piece of evidence to support your thinking.
Choose the answer that completes the sentence below Dyslexic people have trouble reading and understanding text, ______ they often develop ways to cope with dyslexia A. so B. after C. for example D. otherwise
Exercise 1: Choose the best answer A, B or C: 1.My mother used to tell me stories_______________ I went to bed. A.since B.until C.before 2.You better take the keys_______________________ I’m not out. A.
Link Copied!