Question

Objective: Explain how Uprising is structured and identify the unique perspective of each of the

text's protagonists.
Writing Prompt: How do Yetta, Bella, and Jane's perspectives of the Triangle Shirtwaist Factory
differ? Provide three pieces of specific textual evidence that demonstrates each character's
perspective.

Answer 1

1. Yetta's perspective:

- "She [Yetta] knew that if she ever tried to leave the factory, the owners would call the police, and the police would take her back to where she belonged, back to the dirty streets of the Lower East Side" (Chapter 1). This quote shows Yetta's understanding of the power dynamics and her limited options as an immigrant worker.

- "She [Yetta] didn't see how a strike could be anything but dangerous, how striking could be anything but an invitation for the owners to fire everyone, to replace them with new workers, maybe to blacklist the old workers so they could never get another job" (Chapter 9). Yetta's perspective reflects her fear and skepticism towards the idea of striking, as she worries about the potential consequences for the workers.

2. Bella's perspective:

- "Bella had never been inside a factory before, and she had never seen so many workers in one place, hundreds of them, girls sewing at machines or standing over the rows of cutting tables" (Chapter 5). This passage highlights Bella's awe and curiosity as she experiences the factory for the first time.

- "But if Bella really thought about it, she would have to admit that most of the girls in the factory had no future at all. They would stay here until their hands got too twisted with arthritis to thread a needle anymore" (Chapter 6). Bella's perspective reveals her realization of the harsh reality faced by the workers, including their limited prospects for a better future.

3. Jane's perspective:

- "The girls kept trying to explain that the doors had been locked when the fire started, that the fire escape was broken, that the fire department hadn't gotten there in time, that they had died trapped in the factory, but Mr. White wasn't listening" (Chapter 19). This quote illustrates Jane's frustration and anger towards the authorities' dismissal of the workers' concerns and the lack of accountability for the tragedy.

- "Jane wished she could rip the hollowness out of her voice, the numbed feeling, the way the news that there would be no trial, no one punished for the girls' deaths had taken the energy out of her, had made her feel empty" (Chapter 20). Jane's perspective highlights her emotional response to the lack of justice for the victims and her determination to fight for their rights.

Step-by-step explanation:

Answer 2

1. Yetta's perspective:

- "She [Yetta] knew that if she ever tried to leave the factory, the owners would call the police, and the police would take her back to where she belonged, back to the dirty streets of the Lower East Side" (Chapter 1). This quote shows Yetta's understanding of the power dynamics and her limited options as an immigrant worker.

- "She [Yetta] didn't see how a strike could be anything but dangerous, how striking could be anything but an invitation for the owners to fire everyone, to replace them with new workers, maybe to blacklist the old workers so they could never get another job" (Chapter 9). Yetta's perspective reflects her fear and skepticism towards the idea of striking, as she worries about the potential consequences for the workers.

2. Bella's perspective:

- "Bella had never been inside a factory before, and she had never seen so many workers in one place, hundreds of them, girls sewing at machines or standing over the rows of cutting tables" (Chapter 5). This passage highlights Bella's awe and curiosity as she experiences the factory for the first time.

- "But if Bella really thought about it, she would have to admit that most of the girls in the factory had no future at all. They would stay here until their hands got too twisted with arthritis to thread a needle anymore" (Chapter 6). Bella's perspective reveals her realization of the harsh reality faced by the workers, including their limited prospects for a better future.

3. Jane's perspective:

- "The girls kept trying to explain that the doors had been locked when the fire started, that the fire escape was broken, that the fire department hadn't gotten there in time, that they had died trapped in the factory, but Mr. White wasn't listening" (Chapter 19). This quote illustrates Jane's frustration and anger towards the authorities' dismissal of the workers' concerns and the lack of accountability for the tragedy.

- "Jane wished she could rip the hollowness out of her voice, the numbed feeling, the way the news that there would be no trial, no one punished for the girls' deaths had taken the energy out of her, had made her feel empty" (Chapter 20). Jane's perspective highlights her emotional response to the lack of justice for the victims and her determination to fight for their rights.

Step-by-step explanation:

Have a good day <3