216k views
5 votes
Which excerpt(s) feature both syllabic and melismatic settings of the text?

2 Answers

2 votes

Final Answer:

The excerpt featuring both syllabic and melismatic settings of the text is from the choral piece "Ave Maria" by Franz Biebl.

Step-by-step explanation:

"Ave Maria" by Franz Biebl showcases both syllabic and melismatic settings of the text within the choral composition. The piece alternates between sections where the text is set to a single note per syllable (syllabic) and sections where a single syllable is sung across multiple notes (melismatic).

In the syllabic passages, each word or syllable of the text aligns with a single musical note, allowing for clear and straightforward enunciation of the lyrics. This style enhances the listener's understanding of the words being sung as each syllable is distinctly articulated within the music.

Conversely, the melismatic sections involve extended vocal phrases sung over a single syllable or word. Here, the music spans across several notes for a single syllable, creating a flowing and ornamental effect. Melismatic passages often convey emotional depth and intensity by elongating specific words or phrases, allowing for a more intricate and expressive musical interpretation.

Biebl's "Ave Maria" artfully combines these two contrasting musical techniques, interweaving syllabic clarity with melismatic richness throughout the composition. This blend of styles contributes to the overall emotive and captivating nature of the choral piece, offering a dynamic and engaging musical experience for both performers and listeners alike.

User Ndclt
by
8.7k points
5 votes

Final answer:

The question seems to confuse musical terms 'syllabic' and 'melismatic' with the editing and poetic techniques found in Phillis Wheatley's poems. These terms refer to musical note patterns, not typically applied to textual edits or poetry itself. Without musical scores or reference to specific musical settings, determining syllabic and melismatic settings from poetry excerpts is not feasible.

Step-by-step explanation:

The student is asking about musical settings in poetry, particularly the syllabic and melismatic elements. A syllabic setting is when each syllable of a text is matched to a single note, commonly found in many traditional songs and hymns. A melismatic setting, however, is where one syllable is stretched over several notes, which can be heard in genres like gospel or opera. The excerpts presented seem to be focused on Phillis Wheatley's poems and their manuscript variations, which feature editorial marks such as italics and capitalization to emphasize particular words.


While these poetics are apparent within the text, the question is perhaps incorrectly presented, as 'syllabic' and 'melismatic' are terms more commonly used in music rather than poetry. However, the question's connection to musicality in poetry can be addressed through the concepts of rhythm, rhyme, and meter present in Wheatley's work, which mimic musicality and is often a way poetry is differentiated from prose. Nonetheless, without a specific musical setting provided in the excerpts given, identifying syllabic and melismatic settings solely from a poetic standpoint is not possible.

User Tim Visser
by
7.6k points

Related questions

asked Jan 9, 2024 212k views
Azundo asked Jan 9, 2024
by Azundo
7.9k points
1 answer
1 vote
212k views
1 answer
2 votes
190k views