188k views
2 votes
Write a literary analysis that examines the universal themes in Kipling's poem "If-" and Colon's memoir "Kipling and I".

-Follow PEEL paragraph format.
-Multi-paragraph.
-Textual evidence, line number, text the evidence was in.
-Use transitions in text, including when moving into showing textual evidence.

2 Answers

4 votes

Final answer:

The poem 'If-' by Rudyard Kipling and the memoir 'Kipling and I' by Caryl Phillips both explore universal themes of resilience and self-discipline. Both texts emphasize the importance of these themes in overcoming challenges and finding one's identity.

Step-by-step explanation:

Introduction:

The poem 'If-' by Rudyard Kipling and the memoir 'Kipling and I' by Caryl Phillips both explore universal themes that are relevant to people of all cultures and backgrounds. These themes include resilience, self-discipline, and the search for identity. In this literary analysis, we will examine how these themes are portrayed in both texts.

Body Paragraph 1 - Resilience:

In both 'If-' and 'Kipling and I', the theme of resilience is evident. In 'If-', Kipling emphasizes the importance of staying strong and composed even in the face of adversity. He writes, 'If you can meet with Triumph and Disaster / And treat those two impostors just the same' (lines 29-30), highlighting the need to remain steady in both success and failure. Similarly, in 'Kipling and I', Phillips recounts his experiences as an immigrant navigating a new country and culture. Despite facing discrimination and hardships, Phillips maintains resilience and refuses to let these challenges define him. This theme of resilience is a universal one that resonates with readers of all backgrounds.

Body Paragraph 2 - Self-Discipline:

Another universal theme explored in both texts is self-discipline. In 'If-', Kipling emphasizes the importance of self-control and discipline. He advises, 'If you can keep your head when all about you / Are losing theirs and blaming it on you' (lines 1-2), highlighting the need for individuals to remain calm and composed in difficult situations. This theme of self-discipline is also evident in 'Kipling and I' as Phillips reflects on his own journey of self-discovery and the importance of self-discipline in overcoming obstacles. Both texts convey the idea that self-discipline is key to achieving success and overcoming challenges.

Conclusion:

In conclusion, the poem 'If-' by Kipling and the memoir 'Kipling and I' by Phillips both explore universal themes such as resilience and self-discipline. Through their respective texts, both authors emphasize the importance of these themes in navigating life's challenges and finding one's identity. These themes resonate with readers across cultures and serve as valuable life lessons.

User Rakefet
by
8.4k points
3 votes

Answer:

Kipling's poem "If-" and Colon's memoir "Kipling and I" are both literary works that explore universal themes of morality, personal development, and the complexity of human nature. These works, despite being written in different literary forms, offer valuable insights into the human condition and provide guidance on how to navigate the challenges of life.

One universal theme evident in both "If-" and "Kipling and I" is morality. In "If-," Kipling imparts moral wisdom through a series of conditional statements that highlight the importance of integrity and resilience. For instance, Kipling writes, "If you can keep your head when all about you / Are losing theirs and blaming it on you" (1-2). This evidence shows Kipling's emphasis on moral fortitude and the need to remain composed in the face of adversity.

Similarly, in "Kipling and I," Colon reflects on how Kipling's writing influenced his own sense of morality. Colon discusses how Kipling's work served as a moral guide for him, shaping his understanding of right and wrong. For example, Colon states, "Kipling was my moral guide" (Colon, p. 4). This evidence highlights the theme of morality and the impact of literature in shaping one's moral compass.

Another universal theme present in both works is personal development. In "If-," Kipling encourages the reader to strive for self-improvement and to persevere in the face of challenges. He writes, "If you can make one heap of all your winnings / And risk it on one turn of pitch-and-toss" (11-12), emphasizing the importance of taking calculated risks and learning from failures as part of personal growth.

In "Kipling and I," Colon reflects on how Kipling's writing inspired his own personal development. He discusses how Kipling's stories and poems motivated him to work for excellence and for a sense of self-respect. Colon states, "Kipling's words made me feel I had a dignity of my own" (Colon, p. 5). This evidence shows the theme of personal development and the transformative power of literature in shaping an individuals character.

Furthermore, both "If-" and "Kipling and I" delve into the complexity of human nature. In "If-," Kipling acknowledges the contradictions and challenges individuals may face in their pursuit of moral and personal excellence. He writes, "If you can meet with Triumph and Disaster / And treat those two impostors just the same" (23-24), emphasizing the need to maintain equanimity in the face of both success and failure, highlighting the complex nature of human emotions and experiences.

In "Kipling and I," Colon reflects on Kipling's own complexities as a writer and a person. Colon discusses how Kipling's work was both inspiring and controversial, and how his perceptions of Kipling evolved over time. Colon states, "Kipling was a complicated man, and not always a sympathetic one" (Colon, p. 6). This evidence reveals the multifaceted nature of human beings, including their contradictions and imperfections.

In conclusion, Kipling's poem "If-" and Colon's memoir "Kipling and I" share universal themes of morality, personal development, and the complexity of human nature. Through their didactic poetry and personal reflections, these works offer valuable insights into the human condition and provide guidance on navigating life's challenges.

Step-by-step explanation:

Change words to your level of writing and make sure to make it look like your own writing

User Josh Goebel
by
8.0k points