148k views
3 votes
Is it better to be directionally correct across nearly all of the Internet or to be 100% accurate on a small segment of the Internet?

1 Answer

5 votes

Final answer:

The dilemma between being broadly correct versus highly accurate on a specific topic on the Internet relates to the concepts of accuracy and precision. The responsibility of evaluating the reliability of online information falls onto the user, with net neutrality and unrestricted content publication influencing the access to and perception of information.

Step-by-step explanation:

Considering whether it is better to be directionally correct across the Internet or 100% accurate on a small segment of it is a multifaceted issue. This touches upon the concept of accuracy and precision as it pertains to information on the Internet. Accuracy means the closeness of information to the truth or to a specific target, while precision refers to the consistency of the information presented. In the context of the Internet, being directionally correct implies a broader understanding and generalized correctness across various topics, whereas being 100% accurate points to a deep, precise focus on a niche area.

Within this framework, when using a GPS to locate a restaurant, a high accuracy, low precision scenario would entail the GPS locating the restaurant, but with variability in the specific coordinates each time, akin to multiple darts hitting different areas around the target's center. Conversely, a low accuracy, high precision scenario would result in darts landing in close proximity to each other but away from the intended target. The analog to providing information on the Internet would be whether it is more beneficial to have a broad, generally correct base of knowledge, or a smaller but meticulously accurate information set.

The answer may depend on the context and purpose. For instance, in educational settings, accuracy is critical to ensure that students are learning correct information. However, in a conversation, being generally correct might suffice. The responsibility of assessing reliability and precision falls onto the user, and this is complicated by issues such as net neutrality, content saturation, and unrestricted publishing capabilities on the Internet. These factors have a profound impact on how information is accessed and perceived, making issues like Internet tracking and user privacy key points of concern.

User Michael Sofaer
by
8.4k points