Question

Why doesn't the mayor follow his first instinct after finding out that someone else was identified as Jean Valjean?

Answer 1

The mayor doesn't follow his first instinct after someone else is identified as Jean Valjean because he prioritizes justice and truth over personal safety, demonstrating a commitment to his values and principles.

Step-by-step explanation:

In Victor Hugo's "Les Misérables," the mayor, who is actually Jean Valjean, refrains from acting on his initial impulse after another person is identified as Jean Valjean.

This decision is rooted in the mayor's unwavering commitment to justice and truth.

His first instinct may have been motivated by a desire to escape potential consequences or threats to his newfound identity.

However, the mayor's character is defined by a deep sense of moral responsibility and compassion.

Rather than succumbing to self-preservation, he chooses to uphold the principles he believes in.

This decision not only reflects his personal integrity but also sets the stage for the overarching themes of justice and redemption in the narrative.

The mayor's reluctance to follow his initial instinct is a pivotal moment in the story, illustrating the internal struggle between self-interest and a higher moral calling.

This choice contributes to the mayor's complex characterization and lays the foundation for the transformative journey that unfolds throughout the novel.

In summary, the mayor's decision not to follow his first instinct is a testament to his commitment to justice and truth, showcasing the depth of his character and setting the tone for the narrative.

Answer 2

The mayor doesn't follow his first instinct after discovering someone else was identified as Jean Valjean because of his commitment to his principles and the deep sense of responsibility he feels toward the mistaken identity. His decision aligns with his moral code to protect others, even if it means sacrificing his personal interests.

Step-by-step explanation:

The mayor, who is actually Jean Valjean, refrains from acting on his initial impulse due to several reasons deeply rooted in his character. Firstly, he has undergone a transformative journey, embracing a new identity and committing himself to doing good for the community as the mayor. His moral principles drive him to prioritize the well-being of others above his own desires or immediate reactions. Secondly, his past experiences, marked by injustice and suffering, have instilled in him a strong sense of responsibility towards those wrongly accused, motivating him to protect the innocent man identified as Valjean. This decision reflects his growth and dedication to the ideals of justice and compassion.

In Victor Hugo's "Les Misérables," this decision is pivotal as it showcases Valjean's internal conflict and his evolution as a character. His choice not to immediately assert his true identity exemplifies the complexity of human morality and the power of self-sacrifice. Through his actions, Valjean demonstrates a commitment to the greater good, embodying the themes of redemption and selflessness prevalent throughout the novel.

This decision is not solely about self-restraint; it's a testament to Valjean's moral integrity and his unwavering dedication to serving others, showcasing the depth of his character development throughout the narrative.