231k views
4 votes
Roles and responsibilities of local, state, and national governments may overlap creating inefficiencies.

True
False

User Paul Rigor
by
8.7k points

1 Answer

3 votes

Final answer:

The statement that roles and responsibilities of local, state, and national governments may overlap creating inefficiencies is true. Overlap can lead to inefficiencies although it also allows for diverse governance and experimentation. Federal, state, and local governments must collaborate, with federal standards ensuring uniformity and discouraging regulatory races to the bottom.

Step-by-step explanation:

True or False: Roles and responsibilities of local, state, and national governments may overlap creating inefficiencies. The answer to this statement is true. While national, state, and local governments specialize in various policy domains, there can be overlap. National and state governments tend to focus on sectors such as welfare, health, natural resources, and prisons; whereas, local governments often have a significant impact on education, fire protection, and sanitation. Furthermore, there are instances such as the construction of interstate highways that require cooperation and compromise between federal and state governments.

Intergovernmental relationships do allow for experimentation across different "laboratories" of government; however, the necessity for uniform public service provision and the problem of collective action can lead to inefficiencies when overlapping responsibilities occur. The introduction of Dillon's Rule suggests that local governments have the flexibility to make decisions independently, however, in practice, they are still subject to state law and this can limit their autonomy despite perceived freedoms.

State and local governments carry significant weight and their spending has an impact on citizens' lives, often more so than federal spending. Additionally, state and local authorities can be more attuned to the public's needs by virtue of their closeness. Nonetheless, without federal guidance and standards, there could be a race to the bottom in regulatory standards and underfunding in programs with positive externalities.

User Viacheslav Nefedov
by
7.3k points