Final answer:
Yes, it does matter if a New York driver's conviction for an offense like criminal negligence or assault resulting in death occurs in New York state or another state, as states must recognize legal decisions from other states due to the Full Faith and Credit Clause, which could affect licensing and penalties.
Step-by-step explanation:
It does indeed matter if the conviction of any New York driver for criminal negligence, homicide, or assault resulting in death from the operation of a motor vehicle occurs in New York state or another state. The Full Faith and Credit Clause requires each state to recognize the public records, judicial proceedings, and legislative acts of every other state, which means that a conviction in one state can have implications in another state. However, individual state laws and interstate compacts or agreements can affect how convictions in one state are to be treated in another. This could affect licensing, legal penalties, or how points are added to one's driving record. It's also important to note the Privileges or Immunities Clause, requiring states to treat citizens of other states the same as their own citizens.
In the event of a serious crime such as criminal negligence or assault resulting in death, states can and do consider out-of-state convictions. For example, New York might use such a conviction from another state as grounds for revocation or suspension of a driver's license. This is in line with the Apprendi v. New Jersey ruling that requires facts increasing penalties beyond statutory maximums to be proved beyond a reasonable doubt.