115k views
0 votes
Develop an argument in which you evaluate the extent to which state-building practices differed between 1050 and 1500.

1 Answer

4 votes

Final answer:

During the period between 1050 and 1500, state-building practices in England and France differed in terms of constitutionalism, centralized power, and religious conflict. England established constitutional constraints with the Magna Carta, which didn't exist in France. Furthermore, England experienced religious strife and a civil war, while France remained predominantly Catholic and avoided a civil war of the same magnitude.

Step-by-step explanation:

During the period between 1050 and 1500, there were some differences in state-building practices between England and France. In England, the Magna Carta was established in 1215, which implied that all people, including the king, were subject to the law. This document laid the foundation for constitutionalism in England and served as a check on centralized authority. On the other hand, in France, the monarchy held more centralized power without similar constitutional constraints.

Another difference between the two countries was the religious strife they faced. In England, the Protestant Reformation took hold, leading to conflicts between Protestants and Catholics. This eventually culminated in the English Civil War in the 1640s, as different factions fought for control over the country and its government. France, on the other hand, had a strong Catholic influence and did not experience a civil war of the same magnitude during this period.

Overall, the state-building practices in England and France differed in terms of constitutionalism, centralized power, and religious conflict. Despite these differences, both nations were evolving into sovereign states under strong monarchies by the end of the period.

User Scolytus
by
8.2k points