229k views
0 votes
What is the unique contribution of Christianity to the question of evil and suffering?

1 Answer

4 votes

Final answer:

The unique contribution of Christianity to the problem of evil includes Augustine's concept of evil as an absence of good and humanity's fall, as well as Irenaeus' view on evil as necessary for soul-making. These solutions contend with the existence of an all-powerful, all-knowing, and all-loving God in a world where evil persists.

Step-by-step explanation:

The unique contribution of Christianity to the question of evil and suffering lies chiefly in its theological interpretations and narratives. Notably, the Christian perspective introduces two main solutions: the Augustinian and the Irenaean theodicies. Saint Augustine tackled the problem of evil by asserting that evil is not a substance, but rather a 'privation of good' and is the result of free will. This conceptualizes evil not as something created by God but as a result of human choices. Augustine links suffering to the fall of humanity and sees it as a punishment for sin, thereby allowing God to remain aloof from the creation of evil.

Alternatively, Irenaeus offered a developmental and teleological view, positing that evil and suffering contribute to 'soul-making', or the maturation of the human soul towards the divine image. This thought was further developed by modern philosophers like John Hick, who saw the challenges and tribulations of life as the means for spiritual and moral growth, leading to the creation of a truly good person.

However, these solutions do not completely dispel doubts regarding an omnibenevolent, omniscient, and omnipotent deity, as highlighted by the evidential problem of evil, which questions the compatibility of a perfectly good God with the existence of suffering. The Judeo-Christian tradition often addresses this through biblical narratives, like the fall of Lucifer and humanity's temptation to do moral evil, emphasizing human free will and agency.

User Vrs
by
7.5k points