Question

Someone said we can't measure how creative something is, but isn't that completely wrong and dishonest?

Isn't it the same as for intelligence? Isn't measuring intelligence based on a subjective model of intelligence? For example, you need to divide up intelligence into components subjectively and then measure these parts to come with a measure of intelligence such as IQ.

I only asked if there was a way to measure how much more creative a work by Chopin would be compared to a work made by Bach using computational creativity, and someone disingenuously said it was impossible, because it was subjective, but we just need to make a model that allows us to measure how difficult it would be for a computer to generate the same music, and divide it into different components?

Is there anything wrong with what I said?

Answer 1

Measuring creativity can be subjective, but it is not impossible. Experts can assess a work's originality and artistic merit, and the cultural impact of creative figures, such as Picasso, demonstrates the assessable value of creativity.

Step-by-step explanation:

Measuring creativity can indeed be complex because it often involves subjective judgment and incommensurability. While it's true that creative works cannot be quantitatively measured like a cheetah's speed or the Taj Mahal's size, this doesn't mean that creativity is entirely immeasurable. There are qualitative assessments and criteria that experts use to evaluate the originality and artistic merit of a creative work.

Take the example of intellectual property; when a work is copyrighted, a certain acknowledgment is given to its uniqueness and creative value. Similarly, historical perspectives like those of Sir Philip Sydney affirm the value and distinctiveness of creativity in poetry and literature, despite its subjective nature.

Moreover, the impact of transformative figures such as Picasso shows how creative works can indeed be assessed by their influence on a multitude of fields, be it architecture, design, or philosophy. Thus, creativity can be appreciated, if not precisely measured, through its intellectual and cultural significance.