115k views
1 vote
Is a uniform-temperature gas more or less orderly than one with several different temperatures? Which is more structured? In which can heat transfer result in work done without heat transfer from another system?

a) Uniform-temperature gas is less orderly; several temperatures are more structured.
b) Uniform-temperature gas is more orderly; several temperatures are less structured.
c) Both are equally orderly.
d) Heat transfer can't result in work done without heat transfer from another system.

User Skalta
by
8.2k points

1 Answer

5 votes

Final answer:

A uniform-temperature gas is more orderly and structured compared to a gas with regions of different temperatures, which is more disordered. Heat transfer can result in work, but a temperature difference is needed to harness this energy. The correct answer is b) Uniform-temperature gas is more orderly; several temperatures are less structured.

Step-by-step explanation:

In answering the question of whether a uniform-temperature gas is more or less orderly than one with several different temperatures, one must consider the concepts of entropy and disorder. A uniform-temperature gas is inherently more orderly because it has a consistent distribution of molecular speeds and energy levels throughout.

Contrast this with a gas that contains regions of different temperatures; this gas would have a variety of molecular speeds and energy distributions, leading to a more disordered state. As for which is more structured, we can say that the uniform-temperature gas has more structure due to its orderliness.

Regarding the ability to do work without heat transfer from another system, it is a foundational principle of thermodynamics that heat transfer can result in work done, but there must be a temperature difference for this to occur.

Heat naturally flows from hot to cold, and it is this flow, or gradient, that can be harnessed to do work. Therefore, in a system with uniform temperature, there is no gradient to exploit, and spontaneous work cannot be performed without an external input of energy. Thus, the correct answer is b) Uniform-temperature gas is more orderly; several temperatures are less structured.

User Bluszcz
by
7.5k points