Question

What would be the ad hominem response to: We should be socialist because it enables the working class to enjoy the products they produce.

A) You're only saying that because you're a socialist yourself!
B) Your argument is invalid because you're not an economist.
C) This idea is ridiculous, coming from someone who has no business experience.
D) You're just trying to sound smart, but it's not working.

Answer 1

The ad hominem response to the argument for socialism is option A) 'You're only saying that because you're a socialist yourself!', as it attacks the person's motive rather than the argument.

Step-by-step explanation:

An ad hominem response would be one that attacks the person making the argument rather than the argument itself. Looking at the options given, the ad hominem response to 'We should be socialist because it enables the working class to enjoy the products they produce' would be option A) 'You're only saying that because you're a socialist yourself!' This statement disregards the actual argument and instead targets the individual's personal beliefs, suggesting a bias without addressing the merits of the case for socialism.

Answer 2

The ad hominem response would be option A) 'You're only saying that because you're a socialist yourself!'

Step-by-step explanation:

The ad hominem response to the statement 'We should be socialist because it enables the working class to enjoy the products they produce' would be option A) 'You're only saying that because you're a socialist yourself!'

This response attacks the person making the argument rather than addressing the argument itself. It dismisses the argument by suggesting that the person's own beliefs and biases invalidate their position.

It's important to engage in a healthy debate by addressing the merits of the argument rather than attacking the individual.