19.4k views
1 vote
in a review of research by fournier and colleagues (2010) on the effectiveness of antidepressants, why did some studies show antidepressants work, while others showed they were no better than placebos?

User Adam Sharp
by
8.4k points

1 Answer

4 votes

Final answer:

The effectiveness of antidepressants can vary in different studies due to factors such as the placebo effect, variations in study design, and the heterogeneity of depression.

Step-by-step explanation:

Multiple factors can contribute to the different results observed in studies on the effectiveness of antidepressants. One major factor is the placebo effect. In some studies, participants may experience improvements in their symptoms simply because they believe they are receiving an active treatment, even if they are only given a placebo. This can make it difficult to determine the true effectiveness of the antidepressant.

Additionally, variations in study design, sample size, and population characteristics can also influence the outcomes. Different studies may use different measures to assess the effectiveness of antidepressants, leading to varying results.

Moreover, the heterogeneity of depression itself can impact the response to treatment. Depression is a complex disorder with various subtypes and underlying mechanisms. Antidepressants may be more effective for certain subtypes of depression than others, leading to inconsistent findings across studies.

User Kodekan
by
7.8k points