115k views
5 votes
Click to read the passage from "The Chrysanthemums," by John Steinbeck.

Then answer the question.
Which of the following best summarizes the conversation between Elisa and
Henry?
A. Elisa refuses to help on the ranch, and Henry thinks that's fine.
B. Elisa wants to help, and Henry thinks that's a good idea.
C. Elisa does not want to help on the ranch, but Henry would like her
to do so.
D. Elisa says that she can help, but Henry doesn't take her offer
seriously.

User Ballon Ura
by
8.1k points

1 Answer

6 votes

Elisa in "The Chrysanthemums" desires involvement in ranch work, seeking purpose. Henry dismisses her, emphasizing traditional gender roles. Their conversation reflects societal constraints on women's aspirations in the story. So option C is correct

In "The Chrysanthemums" by John Steinbeck, the conversation between Elisa and Henry revolves around Elisa's desire to contribute to ranch work. Elisa, a skilled and passionate gardener, expresses interest in taking on more responsibilities beyond her domestic role. She hints at her longing for a more meaningful connection to the ranch, seeking recognition and a sense of purpose. However, Henry, her husband, fails to grasp the depth of Elisa's aspirations. Instead of encouraging her ambitions, he dismisses her desire to help on the ranch, suggesting that her gardening hobby is sufficient.

The interaction encapsulates the gender dynamics of the time, portraying a society where women were often confined to traditional domestic roles. Elisa's unfulfilled yearning for a more active role in the ranch work reflects the societal constraints placed on women's ambitions and potential.

Therefore, the most fitting summary is option C: Elisa does not want to help on the ranch, but Henry would like her to do so. This encapsulates the essence of their conversation, highlighting Elisa's unfulfilled desire for a more significant role and Henry's lack of understanding or encouragement of her aspirations.

User Sahil Kapoor
by
8.7k points