117k views
2 votes
Karla enters into a contract with Worldwide Enterprises to serve as the company accountant. Worldwide explains to Karla that it is considering selling its assets to another company and needs certain financial documents prepared. Karla prepares financial statements, tax returns, and other financial documents for Worldwide. Neighborhood Sales is considering buying out Worldwide and asks to see Worldwide's financial statements and tax returns, which Worldwide shares with them. Neighborhood Sales purchases Worldwide. Later, Neighborhood Sales discovers there were errors in the financial documents and Worldwide is not worth as much as Neighborhood Sales paid for it. Neighborhood Sales sues Karla for breaching her duty of care in the preparation of the financial statements. If the state law that governs the lawsuit between Neighborhood Sales and Karla follows the Restatement rule:

User Brin
by
8.5k points

1 Answer

5 votes
The Restatement rule refers to the Restatement (Second) of Torts, which provides guidance on negligence and professional duties. In this scenario, if the state law governing the lawsuit between Neighborhood Sales and Karla follows the Restatement rule, it would typically assess whether Karla breached her duty of care as an accountant.

Under the Restatement rule, a professional like Karla owes a duty of care to the parties that she knows will rely on her work, or to those whom she should reasonably foresee as relying on her work, such as prospective buyers of the company (Neighborhood Sales). If Karla prepared the financial statements and other documents with the intent or knowledge that they would be used by prospective buyers like Neighborhood Sales to evaluate the company, she could be held responsible for any errors that result in financial loss.

Neighborhood Sales might argue that Karla breached her duty of care by providing inaccurate financial statements that led to a financial loss when they purchased Worldwide Enterprises. If the court finds that Karla’s errors directly contributed to Neighborhood Sales overpaying for Worldwide, they may hold her accountable for the damages resulting from the inaccurate financial information she provided.
User Khristian
by
8.1k points