211k views
1 vote
How is the ancient Athenians government similar to Swiss government in direct democracy?

User Caliche
by
7.8k points

1 Answer

2 votes

Final answer:

The ancient Athenian government and the modern Swiss government both utilize direct democracy, where citizens vote directly on laws. Athenian democracy was limited to adult, land-owning men, whereas the Swiss system is more inclusive. Both systems value citizen participation in legislative decisions but operate in different contexts and scales.

Step-by-step explanation:

The ancient Athenian government and the modern Swiss government share similarities in their practice of direct democracy. In ancient Athens, direct democracy allowed all male citizens to attend the Assembly, debate, and cast votes on proposed laws. Although this form of government was restricted to adult land-owning men, it gave citizens the unique power to participate directly in government decisions. Similarly, the Swiss system allows citizens to vote directly on various political matters through referendums or initiatives. Both systems bypass the need for representatives to make laws and offer a more direct form of citizen involvement in the legislative process. However, ancient Athens had a limited form of democracy, as it excluded a large portion of the population from the decision-making process, while contemporary Swiss democracy is more inclusive.

While both the Athenian and Swiss models are examples of direct democracy, it is important to note that the context, scale, and inclusiveness of these democracies are quite different. The Athenian model was functional in a relatively small society with clear distinctions among social classes, whereas the Swiss model operates within a modern nation-state, aiming for broader inclusivity.

User Chithri Ajay
by
7.4k points