Question

The knight tells the old woman that she is "low-bred", "old", and "poor". What arguments does the old woman use to teach the knight about nobility, old age, and poverty? Do you think that her arguments are convincing? Use evidence to support your answer.

A) The old woman argues that nobility comes from within and that age is a sign of wisdom. Her arguments are convincing because she changes the knight's attitude.
B) The old woman argues that nobility is determined by lineage, and she challenges the knight's view on old age and poverty. Her arguments are not convincing.
C) The old woman doesn't provide convincing arguments about nobility, old age, or poverty. The knight's attitude remains unchanged.
D) The old woman argues that nobility is about appearance and that old age and poverty are shameful. Her arguments are convincing.

Answer 1

The old woman argues that nobility comes from within and that age is a sign of wisdom. Her arguments are convincing because she changes the knight's attitude.

Step-by-step explanation:

The old woman argues that nobility comes from within and that age is a sign of wisdom. She challenges the knight's view on nobility, old age, and poverty by emphasizing the importance of inner qualities and experiences. For example, she tells the knight that it is better to have a noble heart than to be born into nobility. She also argues that old age brings wisdom and experience that young people lack. Additionally, she points out that poverty does not define a person's worth or nobility.

Her arguments are convincing because she successfully changes the knight's arrogant and judgmental attitude. At the beginning of the story, the knight views nobility based on external factors such as lineage and appearance. However, the old woman's arguments make him realize that true nobility is determined by one's character, wisdom, and actions.