Question

Why would the writer choose to record the experience as a memoir instead of turning it into fiction as a short story? Assume that she is equally skilled in both genres.

a) She wants to be able to add details that she invents, not just ones that she really saw.
b) She wants to persuade readers that some aspects of traditional Inca culture continue to exist.
c) She wants to express her deepest feelings, and the memoir genre will enable her to share them with readers.
d) She wants to describe realistically the way people in Peru today dress, speak, and live.

Answer 1

The writer might opt for a memoir to provide an authentic and emotionally compelling narrative that persuasively shares the continuity of traditional Inca culture, thus deeply engaging the readers.

Step-by-step explanation:

The writer might choose to record the experience as a memoir instead of fictionalizing it into a short story for a few key reasons. One of which is that a memoir can offer a sense of authenticity and personal truth that engages readers on a deeper level. By choosing to write a memoir, the writer can express her deepest feelings and share a genuine and emotionally resonant account of her experiences. Additionally, when writers incorporate cultural aspects and personal anecdotes in their memoirs, they can convey the continuity and presence of traditions, like those of Inca culture, in a way that invites readers to develop empathy and a better understanding of the larger cultural context.

Given such goals, the most apt choice from the given options would be that the writer wants to persuade readers that some aspects of traditional Inca culture continue to exist (option b), as the format of a memoir allows for a personal and culturally rich narrative that is both factually grounded and emotionally compelling.

Answer 2

A writer may choose a memoir over fiction as a short story for emotional expression, realistic description, and audience engagement.

Step-by-step explanation:

A writer may choose to record an experience as a memoir instead of turning it into fiction as a short story for several reasons:

1. Emotional Expression: The writer may want to express their deepest feelings, and the memoir genre allows them to share these emotions with readers.
2. Realistic Description: If the writer wants to accurately describe the way people in Peru today dress, speak, and live, a memoir would be a more suitable genre.
3. Audience Engagement: By writing a memoir, the author can add details that are emotionally authentic and create a composition that resonates with readers on a personal level.