122k views
2 votes
If I said that mineral had "glassy" luster, but you looked at another sample of the same mineral and thought it had a "dull shine", then how could that be? Why isn’t luster a good property to identify minerals on its own?

1 Answer

6 votes

Final answer:

Luster varies in minerals and can be misleading due to factors like surface roughness and impurities. It's categorized into metallic and non-metallic, but is unreliable on its own for identification. More reliable properties include hardness, density, and cleavage, which help geologists determine a mineral's identity.

Step-by-step explanation:

The term luster refers to how light interacts with a mineral's surface, giving it a particular shine or glow. It's essential to understand that luster in minerals can vary, resulting in terms like "glassy" and "dull shine" for the same mineral. This variability is due to factors such as surface roughness, weathering, or the presence of impurities which can alter its appearance.

Luster is categorized broadly into metallic and non-metallic types. Metallic minerals, such as pyrite, have a reflective surface resembling metal and do not allow light to pass through. In contrast, non-metallic minerals, like quartz, might allow some light to pass through, giving them a range of appearances from glassy to dull.

Color is another property that can be used for mineral identification, but it too is unreliable because the same mineral can occur in a variety of colors due to impurities. Instead, properties like hardness, density, and cleavage are often more reliable for identification. Hardness is measured on the Mohs scale and refers to the mineral's ability to scratch or be scratched by other materials. Density is a measure of how much mass a mineral contains in a given volume. Cleavage refers to the tendency of minerals to break along flat, defined planes.

One way to identify cleavage is to shine a light on a mineral's surface; a brilliant reflection typically indicates a cleavage plane. For example, using a cell phone flashlight can help in spotting these planes. Minerals with metallic luster can be identified using a flowchart that looks at various properties, helping to classify and identify them more easily in the field.

Because of the variability and influence of exterior factors, luster is not a definitive property on its own to identify minerals. Accurate identification often requires a combination of observations and sometimes even microscopic examination or chemical analysis. Thus, while observable properties can be quite helpful, especially in fieldwork or educational settings, they have limitations and must be used with caution and in combination with other properties.

User Vladislav Orillo
by
7.6k points