Question

In Romeo and Juliet, Juliet says a rose by another name will smell as sweet. All the family name of Romeo and Juliet make them enemies. Do you think there were agree with this idea? Support your answer with evidence from the story.

A. Yes, Juliet would agree with this idea because she believes love transcends names. She expresses her love for Romeo, despite his family name, Montague.
B. No, Juliet would disagree with this idea because she is deeply concerned about the feud between the Montagues and Capulets, which ultimately leads to tragedy.
C. Juliet's opinion on this idea is unclear in the story, as she never explicitly expresses her view on the significance of names.
D. Juliet's perspective on this idea changes throughout the story, making it difficult to determine whether she would agree or disagree.

Answer 1

Juliet believes that love transcends names, demonstrated by her love for Romeo despite his family name. The tragic outcome of the play underscores the damaging societal impact that names and family feuds can have. Option A is correct answer.

Step-by-step explanation:

In William Shakespeare's Romeo and Juliet, the line "A rose by any other name would smell as sweet" signifies Juliet's belief that a name is simply a label and does not affect the true nature of a person or thing. This sentiment is particularly relevant to the feud between the Capulets and the Montagues, as Juliet acknowledges her deep love for Romeo in spite of his family name being her family's enemy. Therefore, the answer to the question is A: Yes, Juliet would agree with this idea because she believes love transcends names. She expresses her love for Romeo, despite his family name Montague, indicating her disregard for the feud and the power of names. This perspective is consistent throughout the play, as her desire to be with Romeo never wavers, even in the face of family conflict and societal expectations.

The tragic outcome of the story, where both lovers die because of misunderstandings and the pressures of their conflicting families, further emphasizes the societal impact of names and family legacies. The idea that names can bring about such strong emotions and actions, even leading to the ultimate tragedy of the young lovers, demonstrates the complexity behind Juliet's simple yet profound observation.

Shakespeare's exploration of names and identity in Romeo and Juliet continues to resonate in numerous productions of the play across the world, showcasing how the narrative and its underlying themes are interpreted uniquely in each adaptation of this timeless tragedy.