Final answer:
Chase is facing a realization about how his behavior has affected his school reputation, with contrasting explanations of his actions. Feeling shocked upon learning about an arrest is natural, and it's important for Chase to seek a full understanding of his past actions to determine whom to trust.
Step-by-step explanation:
Chase is grappling with the realization that his actions at Hiawassee Middle School have led to differing perceptions; some students are afraid of him, while others view him as famous. The explanations between Aaron and Bear, his mom, and his own understanding of his actions are conflicting. If one were in Chase's position, learning about an arrest due to past actions would likely evoke feelings of shock, disbelief, and a need for self-reflection. Understanding the context of these actions and how they've affected others is crucial. It is important for Chase to consider all viewpoints to form a holistic understanding of the situation and decide for himself who to believe, possibly through introspection or seeking the truth about his past behavior.