Final answer:
The defibrillator turning off is most likely due to dead batteries after the previous crew's use and failure to replace them, which is a common cause for such devices to lose power.
Step-by-step explanation:
The most likely cause of the machine shutting off during resuscitation is that the batteries in the monitor/defibrillator were dead. Given the information that the previous crew used the device and did not replace the batteries, it is reasonable to conclude that the batteries being depleted is the cause of the device powering off. This is more plausible than a malfunction in the power button, a surge caused by the patient's cardiac rhythm, or improper connection by the previous crew, as these are less common occurrences and there is a known history of battery use without replacement.