200k views
1 vote
Task 2: Effect of the Environment on Criminal Behavior

Visit some areas in your community and study their environments, such as the conditions of homes, buildings, businesses, and open spaces. Write about how these conditions may trigger different responses. Then, make an argument for or against positivist theories, which suggest that people may have specific traits that influence how they respond to their social environment.
a) True
b) False

User Jhegedus
by
6.6k points

1 Answer

2 votes

Final answer:

The environment greatly influences criminal behavior, as suggested by Social Disorganization Theory, which focuses on how neighborhood conditions affect a community’s crime rate. Sociologists use data to study environmental influences on crime, and positivist theories argue that personal traits can also influence how an individual responds to social conditions.

Step-by-step explanation:

When considering the effect of the environment on criminal behavior, various factors within a community can trigger different responses. Observing the conditions of homes, buildings, businesses, and open spaces can provide insights into how these factors may encourage or discourage criminal activity. Social Disorganization Theory, a prominent theory in the study of crime geography, posits that neighborhoods create conditions influencing criminal behavior with specific demographic and economic profiles being more prone to criminal activity.

By examining neighborhood variables and community characteristics, sociologists can hypothesize on the social environment's influence on crime rates. For instance, a hypothesis could state that if unemployment in an area increases, there is a likelihood for the crime rate to increase as well. This concept further supports positivist theories which suggest that specific traits might influence how people respond to their social environment.

In studying crime and sociology, researchers use various data sources, including court and police databases, to refine their hypotheses and understand the broader trends. By employing statistical analysis and tools like GIS (Geographic Information System), they can identify how certain businesses or institutions, like payday lenders, can influence crimes rates in addition to the neighborhood characteristics.

- Argument for Positivist Theories

Arguing for positivist theories, one could say that observable evidence supports the notion that specific traits in individuals and conditions in their environments do shape behavior, including tendencies toward crime. The data from these studies can be leveraged to inform policy and intervention strategies, aiming to mitigate crime by addressing environmental factors in tandem with inherent individual traits.

User Ronan Jouchet
by
7.4k points