112k views
1 vote
A student placed three identical plant seedlings in soil in three identical containers. What variable is the student manipulating in this experiment?

a) Soil type
b) Amount of water
c) Height of seedlings
d) Number of containers

User Mlagma
by
7.6k points

1 Answer

7 votes

Final answer:

The student has not indicated manipulation of any specific variable in their plant seedling experiment. To conduct a valid experiment, one variable must be manipulated while others are controlled. Without additional information, we cannot determine which variable is being tested.

Step-by-step explanation:

The student in the scenario is manipulating no specific variable as the information given does not indicate any changes or differences being applied to the plant seedlings or their growing conditions. To properly conduct an experiment, the student would need to change one factor, such as soil type, amount of water, height of seedlings or number of containers, while keeping all other variables constant. However, without further information, we cannot determine which variable is being tested.

Considering other scenarios provided for context, it seems the experiments generally aim to understand plant growth under different conditions. These include the type of soil, amount of water, and exposure to light or certain substances. To test a hypothesis, it's crucial that only one variable is changed at a time (the independent variable), while all others are kept constant to ensure any observed changes in the plant growth (the dependent variable) can be attributed to the manipulation of that single factor.

In an experiment, controlling these factors allows for a fair test, providing reliable results from which a conclusion can be drawn. If a student does not have an experimental control or if there are uncontrolled variables, such as those mentioned like soil temperature or water loss due to evaporation, the reliability of the experiment's outcome can be compromised.

User Cyberdantes
by
8.1k points