50.5k views
2 votes
Do you think this story would have been different if adults had been trapped on the island instead of children? Why or why not?

a) Yes, because adults are more responsible.
b) No, because human nature transcends age.
c) Partially true, as maturity levels differ.
d) True, as adults would have found a solution sooner.

User Luiz Lago
by
7.3k points

1 Answer

6 votes

Final answer:

The story would have been different if adults had been trapped on the island instead of children. One reason is that adults are generally more responsible and may have been able to find a solution to their situation sooner than children. However, human nature transcends age and the same conflicts and power struggles would likely still occur.

Step-by-step explanation:

The story would have been different if adults had been trapped on the island instead of children. One reason is that adults are generally more responsible and may have been able to find a solution to their situation sooner than children. However, it is also important to consider that human nature transcends age. This means that the same conflicts, power struggles, and dynamics would likely still occur, regardless of whether the individuals trapped on the island were children or adults.

For example, in William Golding's novel Lord of the Flies, the group of boys who are stranded on an island quickly descend into chaos and conflict, despite being children. This suggests that no matter the age group, the innate human nature and the struggle for power and control would still be present.

Therefore, the story would have been different, but not drastically so. While adults may have brought their maturity and responsibility to the situation, they would still face the same challenges and conflicts inherent in human nature.

User LeonardChallis
by
8.0k points