149k views
1 vote
In "Indio Muerto to be Renamed Hutash Street," historian Neal Graffy argues for keeping

the original street named in 1851 after the body of a Native American found there.
What words did he actually use to justify his view?
O "For 169 years, Indio Muerto Street is the only monument to the burial place of an unknown
man who died alone in the empty fields of Santa Barbara. To rename this street is to remove his
headstone and any memory of his existence."
O "Practically all Santa Barbara's Street names are Spanish and since most people don't speak
Spanish what's the problem?"
O "Indio Muerto is not offensive and anyone who says it is is a liberal snowflake who doesn't
appreciate history."
O "Let's rename San Andres Street 'Dead Frenchman's Street and Figueroa 'Dead White Lady's
Street. Didn't that one woman get hit by a bus there?"

User Weaver
by
9.1k points

1 Answer

4 votes

Final answer:

In his article, historian Neal Graffy justifies keeping the street named Indio Muerto by emphasizing its historical significance and opposing the removal of a monument to an unknown man. He also provides alternative street names to demonstrate the importance of preserving historical names.


Step-by-step explanation:

Historian Neal Graffy argues for keeping the original street named Indio Muerto in his article titled 'Indio Muerto to be Renamed Hutash Street.' He justifies his view by stating that for 169 years, Indio Muerto Street has been a monument to the burial place of an unknown man who died in Santa Barbara. He argues that renaming the street would remove his headstone and erase any memory of his existence. Graffy also does not find the name offensive and disagrees with those who claim it is. He provides examples by suggesting alternative street names such as 'Dead Frenchman's Street' and 'Dead White Lady's Street' to highlight the historical significance of street names.


Learn more about Historical significance of street names

User Cyram
by
8.1k points