138k views
1 vote
What were differences and similarities between the historical macbeth and the one in shakespeare’s play?

2 Answers

7 votes

Final answer:

The historical Macbeth was a Scottish king with a relatively stable reign, while Shakespeare's character is a dramatized nobleman driven by ambition and destined for downfall. Shakespeare's play introduced supernatural themes and served as a political commentary for the Jacobean audience, whereas the historical Macbeth's rule does not carry such narratives.

Step-by-step explanation:

The historical Macbeth was King of Scotland from 1040 to 1057, known for a reign that brought relative stability and prosperity to the kingdom. In contrast, William Shakespeare's Macbeth is characterized more by its dramatic portrayal of a nobleman overcome by ambition, driven to murder, and eventually descending into tyranny and madness. The real Macbeth secured the throne by killing King Duncan I, although accounts suggest this was in battle rather than the treacherous manner depicted in the play. Still, some similarities exist in their rise to power and initial successes as rulers.

Shakespeare dramatized Macbeth's story to suit the tastes of the Jacobean audience and to align with King James I's interests, who believed himself to be a direct descendent of the historical Banquo, portrayed as noble and virtuous in the play. The Bard took creative liberties, incorporating supernatural elements such as witches and prophecies to captivate the audience and underpin themes of fate versus free will. This juxtaposition between the true events and Shakespeare's narrative illustrates the transformation of historical figures into dramatic characters for the purpose of storytelling and political commentary.

Overall, while the real Macbeth was a monarch who ruled effectively for 17 years, Shakespeare's version serves to highlight the destructive nature of unchecked ambition and the consequences of moral corruption.

User Rock Lee
by
7.2k points
3 votes

Answer:

King Macbeth/Shakespeare’s Macbeth

Becomes king after defeating King Duncan I in battle/Murders to become king

Must protect his kingdom from outside attacks/Murders more to protect his throne

Well-liked king who promoted Christianity and had peace for many years/Dangerous, impulsive leader

Killed in battle by Malcolm Ill/Killed in battle by Macduff

No evidence of witchcraft in his rule/Consulted witches multiple times to secure throne

Hope it helped! :)

User Casey Fleser
by
7.3k points