Question

PLEASE HELP 25 POINTS IF RIGHT

Stopping the expansion of Muslim states and reclaiming the Holy Land in the Middle East was one of the primary motives of the Crusades. The question is, did they achieve this goal overall? Were they successful in reclaiming the Holy Land?

Your assignment is to write a news article analyzing if the crusaders succeeded in any of the goals they set out to achieve. As a journalist, your goal is to write a clear concise summary for your readers, and to support your writing with evidence. Analyze the leaders, the battles, and the consequences of this competition for the Holy Land.

Your article should include three complete paragraphs: one about the successes of the Crusades, one about the failures of the Crusades, and the last one declaring your overall position of whether the Crusades were more of a success or more of a failure. Be sure to acknowledge all of the Crusades listed in the lesson to make sure your writing is well supported. You do not need to analyze the Children's Crusade.

Crusades Covered in Lesson
First Crusade (1096-1099)
Second Crusade (1147-1149)
Third Crusade (1187-1192)
Fourth Crusade (1202-1204)
Final Crusades (1217-1272)










Items to include in the three paragraphs:

Details about the events
Key figures
Short- and long-term benefits/consequences
Geographic effects
The following key people and terms should all appear:
Urban II Richard
Pilgrims Saladin
Seljuk Turks Latin Empire

Answer 1

After years of Muslim states expanding their territories, the primary motive of the Crusades was to stop this expansion and reclaim the Holy Land. But did the Crusaders achieve this goal? Let's analyze the successes and failures of the Crusades to determine whether they were more of a success or more of a failure.

Successes of the Crusades:

One of the most significant successes of the Crusades was the establishment of the Latin Kingdom of Jerusalem. This success occurred during the First Crusade (1096-1099) and allowed the Crusaders to establish a Christian state in the Holy Land. Additionally, the Crusaders managed to capture several other cities, including Antioch and Edessa.

Failures of the Crusades:

Despite these successes, the Crusaders ultimately failed to achieve their primary goal of reclaiming the Holy Land. The Crusaders suffered significant defeats, including the loss of Jerusalem to Saladin during the Third Crusade (1187-1192). Moreover, the Fourth Crusade (1202-1204) was a complete disaster and saw the Crusaders attack Constantinople, resulting in the Latin Empire replacing the Byzantine Empire.

Overall Position:

The Crusades were more of a failure than a success. Despite their initial success in establishing the Latin Kingdom of Jerusalem, the Crusaders were unable to reclaim the Holy Land and ultimately suffered significant defeats. Additionally, the Crusades resulted in the loss of countless lives, including innocent civilians, and sparked long-term conflicts and tensions between Christians and Muslims.

In conclusion, while the Crusades may have achieved some success in establishing a Christian state in the Holy Land, their overall failure to reclaim the Holy Land and the negative consequences that followed make them more of a failure than a success.