First, we find the diagonal with Bill's measurements. To do that, we apply Pythagorean's Theorem to the below
This means, if Bill want to do a rectangular deck with dimensions 15 by 8, he should have a diagonal of 17.
On the other hand, Tyrone noticed that a 15 feet diagonal is enough, which means Bill had wrong the dimensions of the rectangular deck he wants.
Therefore, Tyrone should tell Bill that he did a mistake with the measures.