228k views
0 votes
Jack boasts that his tribe does whatever he wants. Why is this true? Why might the boys prefer Jack's leadership to Ralph's?

User Sormuras
by
9.0k points

2 Answers

4 votes
Jack has a more appealing leadership because he campaigns that his tribe will have fun and hunt for pigs (which is appealing to the protein deprived children). Ralph and Piggy don't try to make the situation fun, they realise that they have things they need to do in order to survive and especially in order to be rescued. They build shelters, firewood, and take care of the little-uns. This is all very exhausting unappealing work for boys of their age who aren't all at the maturity Ralph, Piggy, Simon, and the twins seem to have. They would rather chant war calls and run around than to work and worry. (Haven't read this book in awhile but I hope this helps!)
User Erik Peterson
by
8.6k points
7 votes

Leadership in small groups and societies is often situational and based on prowess and personality. The boys may prefer Jack's leadership over Ralph's because Jack has an absolute advantage in various camping tasks, making him more efficient and skilled in those activities.

In small groups and societies, leadership is often situational and based on prowess and personality. It is not uncommon for individuals to take the lead in different activities or situations, such as hunting, gathering, or religious rituals. This is the case in many hunter-gatherer societies, as well as lineage-order societies in Melanesia and New Guinea.

In the context of the question, Jack boasts that his tribe does whatever he wants because he has demonstrated his leadership skills and abilities. He may have proven himself as a successful hunter, gatherer, or in other activities that are valued by the group. His persuasive power and ability to attract followers may also contribute to his claim.

The boys in the group may prefer Jack's leadership to Ralph's because Jack has an absolute advantage in various aspects of their camping activities, as described in the information provided. Jack is faster and more skilled in tasks such as carrying a backpack, gathering firewood, setting up tents, and making meals. His expertise and efficiency make him an effective leader in the context of their camping adventures.

User Steve Kamau
by
9.1k points