240,423 views
35 votes
35 votes
Read the excerpt from an essay about poets written by Ralph Waldo Emerson in 1844.

Those who are esteemed umpires of taste are often persons who have acquired some knowledge of admired pictures or sculptures, and have an inclination for whatever is elegant; but if
you inquire whether they are beautiful souls, and whether their own acts are like fair pictures, you learn that they are selfish and sensual. Their cultivation is local, as if you should rub a log
of dry wood in one spot to produce fire, all the rest remaining cold. Their knowledge of the fine arts is some study of rules and particulars, or some limited judgment of color or form, which is
exercised for amusement or for show. It is proof of the shallowness of the doctrine of beauty as it lies in the minds of our amateurs, that men seem to have lost the perception of the instant
dependence of form upon soul. There is no doctrine of forms in our philosophy. We were put into our bodies, as fire is put into a pan to be carried about, but there is no accurate adjustment
between the spirit and the organ, much less is the latter the germination of the former. So in regard to other forms, the intellectual men do not believe in any essential dependence of the
material world on thought and volition. Theologians think it a pretty air-castle to talk of the spiritual meaning of a ship or a cloud, of a city or a contract, but they prefer to come again to the
solid ground of historical evidence; and even the poets are contented with a civil and conformed manner of living, and to write poems from the fancy, at a safe distance from their own
experience. But the highest minds of the world have never ceased to explore the double meaning, or shall I say the quadruple or the centuple or much more manifold meaning, of every
sensuous fact; Orpheus, Empedocles, Heraclitus, Plato, Plutarch, Dante, Swedenborg, and the masters of sculpture, picture, and poetry.
Identify the sentence or phrase that serves as the rebuttal in the excerpt.
O "But the highest minds of the world have never ceased to explore the double meaning, or shall I say the quadruple or the centuple or much more manifold meaning, of every
sensuous fact; Orpheus, Empedocles, Heraclitus, Plato, Plutarch, Dante, Swedenborg, and the masters of sculpture, picture, and poetry."
O'Theologians think it a pretty air-castle to talk of the spiritual meaning of a ship or a cloud, of a city or a contract, but they prefer to come again to the solid ground of historical
evidence..."
O'Their knowledge of the fine arts is some study of rules and particulars, or some limited judgment of color or form, which is exercised for amusement or for show."
O "We were put into our bodies, as fire is put into a pan to be carried about; but there is no accurate adjustment between the spirit and the organ, much less is the latter the
germination of the former."

User Zeugor
by
3.0k points

2 Answers

13 votes
13 votes

Final answer:

The rebuttal in Emerson's essay is the sentence that contrasts the superficial taste of some individuals with the profound exploration of sensuous facts by historical intellectuals and artists.

Step-by-step explanation:

In the excerpt from an essay about poets by Ralph Waldo Emerson, the sentence that serves as a rebuttal is: "But the highest minds of the world have never ceased to explore the double meaning, or shall I say the quadruple or the centuple or much more manifold meaning, of every sensuous fact; Orpheus, Empedocles, Heraclitus, Plato, Plutarch, Dante, Swedenborg, and the masters of sculpture, picture, and poetry." Emerson is criticizing the superficial understanding of beauty and artistic cultivation by certain people who only value elegance and taste without depth. This rebuttal offers a contrast by citing historical figures who probed deeper into the layers of sensuous facts, suggesting that true understanding involves exploring the complex interplay between form and soul, or the physical and the spiritual.

User Paddy Mann
by
2.6k points
16 votes
16 votes

Answer:

"But the highest minds of the world have never ceased to explore the double meaning, or shall I say the quadruple or the centuple or much more manifold meaning, of every sensuous fact; Orpheus, Empedocles, Heraclitus, Plato, Plutarch, Dante, Swedenborg, and the masters of sculpture, picture, and poetry."

Step-by-step explanation:

Took the Segment Exam.

User Jackkobec
by
3.0k points