Question

Which statement is an example of big-picture feedback?

O
A. "Your introduction is very interesting and really draws the reader in
to what you will focus on in your essay."
O
B. 'You do an excellent job refuting your opponent's claims and
providing reasons why they are not valid."
O
C. 'Your sentences are beautifully written, especially when you write
about your first visit to the lighthouse."
O
D. "You need to do a better job proofreading: I found several typos
and spelling errors in the introduction of your paper."

Answer 1

B since it’s giving specific details on the writing.

Answer 2

B). 'You do an excellent job refuting your opponent's claims and providing reasons why they are not valid."

Step-by-step explanation:

'Big-picture' feedback, as the title itself, suggests that 'an overall and broad assessment of a situation, activity, or its results.' The second option exemplifies the big-picture feedback as it focuses on the entire content of the work while the other options merely concern a specific element(introduction, writing style, or proofreading). It reveals the entire perspective on the work that 'how the counterclaims have been intelligibly refuted through logic and reason' that offers a clear and comprehensive evaluation of the work. Thus, option B is the correct answer.