Question

Do you agree with Milton Babbit's idea that modern composers should forget about the audience and retreat to writing in private for themselves and other music professionals? Explain your answer in a paragraph of no less than 125 words.

Answer 1

I do not fully agree with Milton Babbit's idea that modern composers should forget about the audience and write in private. Composers should consider the audience while maintaining their artistic vision and expression.

Step-by-step explanation:

In my opinion, I do not fully agree with Milton Babbit's idea that modern composers should forget about the audience and retreat to writing in private for themselves and other music professionals. While it is important for composers to express their creativity and individuality, it is equally important to consider the audience and their reception of the music. Music is a form of communication, and the audience plays an essential role in this interaction. By writing solely for themselves and other music professionals, composers may limit the accessibility and enjoyment of their music to a wider audience.

There are renowned composers who have successfully pushed the boundaries of music by challenging the audiences of their time, such as Berlioz, Strauss, and Wagner. They were able to maintain artistic integrity while still engaging and captivating their audience. Composers should strive to strike a balance between their own artistic vision and the appreciation and connection of their listeners. This can lead to more meaningful and impactful compositions that resonate with a broader audience.

Ultimately, it is crucial for composers to consider the audience while not compromising their artistic expression. By understanding and engaging with the audience, composers can create music that is both meaningful to them and accessible to others, fostering a deeper connection between the composer, the performers, and the listeners.

Answer 2

Step-by-step explanation:

Yes, I do agree with that idea simply because I feel like music should be written for one's pure enjoyment. The artist should not have to worry about criticism from others as long as they enjoy their piece that should be the only thing that matters. Why should society get a choice in what the artist should be feeling or writing. The artist composes music through their own feelings and that's how they are able to express themselves.